What's the big deal in this burg? Not sports. Not theatre. We're talking restaurants.
Restaurants are a huge deal in Montreal and I propose that we formally promote our identity as a restaurant capital.
How? With a restaurant museum. The museum would feature some of the great lost Montreal restaurants and try to recapture their ambiance. So here, are my suggestions of our lost restaurants that should be recaptured at Montreal's restaurant museum.
Desjardins: This joint on Mackay above Dorch started life as an oyster stand on Peel and St. Antoine, then moved ot Guy and Dorch and then to Mackay in 1950. It's the only downtown building built specifically as a restaurant but for the last several years (anybody know the exact date of its closing?) it still sits as a pathetic empty shell. Albert Desjardins was the big daddy of the joint but he died in 1980 and sold it to Barry Kaufman who built a big glass atrium on the front, it was considered pretentious and overpriced. Noriko Ishii, who owned another Japanese restaurant on Mountain purchased it in 1994 and turned it into a sushi joint but it did not last. I'd love to see it brought back to life in its earliest form, a small oyster stand.
For 80 pages of Montreal restaurant history plus many other delightful chapters, be sure to purchase my book Montreal 375 Tales

Eaton's Ninth Floor Cafeteria: Supposedly this gym-sized Art Deco showplace modelled after the opulent Ile-de- France ocean liner has been preserved as a heritage site. I seem to recall it closed sometime prior to the store closing in 1999. (In fact, this might be the ideal spot for the restaurant museum, with part of it preserved and the rest given over to imitations of other joints).
Drury's Restaurant: this old-fashioned British chop shop sat at the SW corner of whats now Dominion Square. If featured a number of small rooms and reasonably-priced meals and the Habs owner Leo Dandurand was the proprietor after buying it off the eponymous prior owners. It was a laid-back, comfy slow-dining place popular with bigshots from out of town and sportsmen. Dreapeau ordered Osborne St. (the continuation of La Gauch east of Peel) demolished but made plans to save the building but his brief-successor Sarto Fournier had it demolished in 1959.
Bens Delicatessan: Best-known as the original place for smoked meat in Montreal and for being open pretty much the entire night. The location was also useful as it kept an office-canyon area alive. The framed 8x10 glossies and old time counters and white-and-black clad waiters also brought a certain style to the joint.
Joe Beef closed down in the spring of 1962, which makes this the 50th anniversary of its closure, something that somebody might think of marking. Of course in its later days on Common, the owner had long since died and the informal zoo long gone but the legend certainly lives to this day.
Au Lutin Qui Bouffe: This joint just up there east of St. Denis had the gimmick of letting you take your photo with a little piglet and it also was the scene of a dramatic robbery in which the owner was killed and the murdered tracked down months later in Texas. I think one of Conrad Black's close associates was involved in the ownership at one time too.
The Kon Tiki: Montreal hasn't had a good tiki bar since this joint closed and everybody should enjoy travelling to the Pacific within their own city at least once in a lifetime.
Others: Ogilvy's basement cafeteria (a personal favourite) which closed in the late 1980s, Cordner's, The Traymore, Roncarelli's, The Bonfire.
I also have a vague recollection of a cafeteria-type restaurant somewhere near Simpson's where the gimmick was that countless plates sat behind glass doors and you just slid the door and grabbed the one you wanted.
Please add you suggestions for restaurants that should be considered for this list.
Restaurants are a huge deal in Montreal and I propose that we formally promote our identity as a restaurant capital.
How? With a restaurant museum. The museum would feature some of the great lost Montreal restaurants and try to recapture their ambiance. So here, are my suggestions of our lost restaurants that should be recaptured at Montreal's restaurant museum.
Desjardins: This joint on Mackay above Dorch started life as an oyster stand on Peel and St. Antoine, then moved ot Guy and Dorch and then to Mackay in 1950. It's the only downtown building built specifically as a restaurant but for the last several years (anybody know the exact date of its closing?) it still sits as a pathetic empty shell. Albert Desjardins was the big daddy of the joint but he died in 1980 and sold it to Barry Kaufman who built a big glass atrium on the front, it was considered pretentious and overpriced. Noriko Ishii, who owned another Japanese restaurant on Mountain purchased it in 1994 and turned it into a sushi joint but it did not last. I'd love to see it brought back to life in its earliest form, a small oyster stand.
****
***

Eaton's Ninth Floor Cafeteria: Supposedly this gym-sized Art Deco showplace modelled after the opulent Ile-de- France ocean liner has been preserved as a heritage site. I seem to recall it closed sometime prior to the store closing in 1999. (In fact, this might be the ideal spot for the restaurant museum, with part of it preserved and the rest given over to imitations of other joints).
Drury's Restaurant: this old-fashioned British chop shop sat at the SW corner of whats now Dominion Square. If featured a number of small rooms and reasonably-priced meals and the Habs owner Leo Dandurand was the proprietor after buying it off the eponymous prior owners. It was a laid-back, comfy slow-dining place popular with bigshots from out of town and sportsmen. Dreapeau ordered Osborne St. (the continuation of La Gauch east of Peel) demolished but made plans to save the building but his brief-successor Sarto Fournier had it demolished in 1959.
Bens Delicatessan: Best-known as the original place for smoked meat in Montreal and for being open pretty much the entire night. The location was also useful as it kept an office-canyon area alive. The framed 8x10 glossies and old time counters and white-and-black clad waiters also brought a certain style to the joint.
Joe Beef closed down in the spring of 1962, which makes this the 50th anniversary of its closure, something that somebody might think of marking. Of course in its later days on Common, the owner had long since died and the informal zoo long gone but the legend certainly lives to this day.
Au Lutin Qui Bouffe: This joint just up there east of St. Denis had the gimmick of letting you take your photo with a little piglet and it also was the scene of a dramatic robbery in which the owner was killed and the murdered tracked down months later in Texas. I think one of Conrad Black's close associates was involved in the ownership at one time too.
The Kon Tiki: Montreal hasn't had a good tiki bar since this joint closed and everybody should enjoy travelling to the Pacific within their own city at least once in a lifetime.
Others: Ogilvy's basement cafeteria (a personal favourite) which closed in the late 1980s, Cordner's, The Traymore, Roncarelli's, The Bonfire.
I also have a vague recollection of a cafeteria-type restaurant somewhere near Simpson's where the gimmick was that countless plates sat behind glass doors and you just slid the door and grabbed the one you wanted.
Please add you suggestions for restaurants that should be considered for this list.






How about Miss Montreal on Decarie near de la Savanne. Great place after a movie. Best strawberry shortcake.
ReplyDeleteAll the restaurants in the Murray's chain, and any Montreal restaurant with "Miss" in the name. Miss Westmount, Miss Montreal, Miss Dixie...
ReplyDeletePeabody
Sorry I hadn't read the previous comment about Miss Montreal when I posted.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, all those other Misses and near-Misses.
Peabody
You could also mention Chez Pauzé on St. Catherine where 3 Amigos sits now. Or how about Kyoto, or the Magic Pan? Outside the city core how about Piazza Tomasso on Decarie or the Klondike Steakhouse in St. Laurent with it giant neon sign.
ReplyDeleteRegarding Eaton's:
The 9th floor dining room and access hallways have been not been touched since they closed, but are not exactly well preserved either. Floor boards have popped up and lots of paint is peeling away. Its vocation as a restaurant is gone forever as the imposing kitchen wasn't included in the preservation plans; it's now office space. The chicken pot pie was my favorite dish.
Eaton's had two other places to grab a bite. On the metro level was the Eaton restauant. It was cafeteria-style with a nice sitting area.
On the 5th floor (toy floor) you had a small snack bar which was orginally an Automat.
And for to-go goodies and sweet treats, the Eaton Gourmet boutique on the metro level was the place to go; their doughnuts were the best I've ever had You could get the chicken pot pie here in a ready to heat & serve container, too.
Oh, and Desjardins seafood closed in 2003.
ReplyDeleteHowdy!
ReplyDeleteScrew eating, what about bringing back the Toe Blake Tavern? Henri Richard's? Butch Bouchard's? The Royal? The Tramway?
Heck fast forward a couple of years, The Double Deuce. Cafe Campus on Decelles. The possibilities are endless!
It was the Traymore which was the first cafeteria in Montreal, but also had the "Automat" section where you chose your food from behind a glass door. Int he basement on Ste Catherine just west of Peel (north side) where one of the Peel Pubs would later be located.
ReplyDeleteDesjardins at one time let you choose the live fish you wanted (or even catch it) and then they would bring it to you dead and with vegetables.
"they would bring it to you dead and with vegetables" One of the funniest lines ever
DeleteHanford Woods!! Long time no see. How's your brother Tom?
DeleteI miss Murray's, especially in the winter. The last one closed a couple of years ago and is now some sort of breakfast joint. I vaguely remember that restaurant near Simpson's but never ate there. There used to be a really good sushi joint on Crescent, gone now, Sushi Maki i think it was called.
ReplyDeleteI remember the Continental downtown which served that incredible onion soup with the thick cheese crust!
ReplyDeleteJeezuz...that did it! Surely another restaurant has it on their menu? If anyone knows where it is, please post it here.
About the "cafeteria-style" restaurant on Ste. Catherine St., I will guess that this might be the old Kresge's place on the north side just west of McGill College. That entire block was demolished and replaced by Place Montreal Trust.
ReplyDeleteI also recall another cafeteria on the north side of St. Jacques, east of McGill St. in Old Montreal.
The Customs House on McGill St. also use to have a great cafeteria mainly to for its employees, but anyone could take the elevator upstairs and gorge themselves.
Such cafeterias are sadly missed. I suspect the A&W, being one of the first fast-food chains here in the mid sixties, followed around 1974-75 by the first McDonald's, sounded the death knell for cafeterias.
The CN office building has one at the top of the escalator (also accessible to the public) west of the taxi entrance to Central Station.
Bon appetit!
Best ribs were either at Rib Tickler or La Dilligence/Stage coach.
ReplyDeletePumpernicks. Best black forest cake -- ever
The sad thing is that most of restaurants has been closed.. :(
ReplyDeleteGlad someone mentioned Murray's. I am old enough to have eaten in all the pictured restaurants although I missed Joe Beef's. Would add La Tour Eiffel- Stanley above Ste. Catherine- and the Cavalier Room in the nearby LaSalle Hotel.
ReplyDeleteI would agree that Kresge's was the cafeteria style restaurant, remember sitting right next to Jackie Vernon wonderful comedian he loved this city and the food, another great restaurant was Paesano's on Cote-des-Neiges, amazing Italian food, Chalet Lucerne BBQ near Guy not the great Chalet BBQ, but came close
ReplyDeleteI remember Sammy's Train Station near Jean-Talon & Victoria. Also Crickets had all the arcade games!
ReplyDeleteGreat stuff (for us old timers?).
ReplyDeleteMay I add: up until some time in The Coffee Mill on Stanley was THE place to go for cheese cake, if you wanted something other than the classic Montreal-style cheese cake at Dunn's.
Stanley is still a pretty good restaurant street, though, even if the places have changed.
Wasn't there also a great place called Stash's on Mackay, where Nick used to go? Great for tea and cakes and European dishes, as I recall.
We should be grateful, I suppose, that we still have one Steerburger left. Did there not used to be a second down by the Bay/Morgans?
Stash's is now on rue St-Paul in Old Montreal.
DeleteKrakovie had a great $2.97 tax-free lunch special in the early
ReplyDelete'80s. I think this restaurant moved from the downtown core though.
Peabodzje.
So glad Marc mentioned the donuts in the Eaton Metro level, because every time I do, I come off sounding like a pig. But god, they WERE amazing. Don't ask me how.
ReplyDeleteAnd thanks to Bill for citing Kresge's. I get them and their adjacent Woolworth's mixed up some time, but I think it was K's little glazed pink and chocolate cakes with the silver ball atop that send me into kiddie nirvana.
Our mom knew we loved them, god bless her, and she indulged us. I miss her.
I can see my late grandfather frowning at me as I forgot the Brown Derby on Van Horne.
ReplyDeleteSammy's was originally called The Victoria Station, then became Sammy's, then it closed.
Can someone please help me with one thing: I recall going to an automat with my mom in what is now/was recently the Centraide greystone building on Sherbrooke and I guess Aylmer.
ReplyDeleteMy older brother has no recollection of it.
Does anyone recall this place, or have I just got it mixed up with one of the other automats mentioned here?
Thanks
I think it was called HONEYDEW
DeleteThen there was Dinty Moore's at 1236 Ste. Catherine St. west of Drummond.
ReplyDeleteMy parents would take me there a lot when I was a little kid. Funny, but I can't recall what kind of food they served, but I do remember for some reason being fascinated by the round, fake "porthole windows" on the walls.
How about the original Dagwood's restaurant near the corner of Cote Vertu and Laurentian Blvd. (now called Marcel Laurin), and the Astor at 688 Ste. Catherine St. across from Eaton's, since replaced by Nickel's.
See: http://acanadianfamily.com/2011/01/30/montreals-astor-restaurant-bar-and-cocktail-lounge-montreal-history-george-spero-gavaris/
Also popular were the Honey Dew, the Black Orchid, the Indian Room, and The Chick'n Coop which I remember in the '50s and '60s.
I have fond memories of the Jasmine Café on LaGauchetière in Chinatown of course. As a kid, I had the privilege of meeting Ted Ziegler (Johnny Jellybean) there when he sauntered in to pick up some take-out for the boys at CFCF. He sat in a chair next to the kitchen while a parade of kids, me included, would gather in awe, wanting to see him in person. He was just great. I'm pretty sure the cooks took their time on purpose to get his order ready as this was great PR for them.
ReplyDelete@ Shawn in Montreal:
ReplyDeleteThe Centraide building was for many years a Jewish community centre. Perhaps it was that?
I am sure you just plain forgot the glorious Cafe Martin...
ReplyDeleteThe Barnsider on Guy St between Sherbrooke & De Maisonneuve.
ReplyDeleteFond memories and one I'd rather forgot (not the restaurant, but my dining companion was the problem). :)
DeleteThe Barnsider, classic, was it called the Barnsider Sirloin Pit? seem to remember eating off wooden steak boards,also great memories of the Klondike Steak house on Cote-de-Liesse
ReplyDeleteFor tiki, a lot of what was in Kon-Tiki is now in Jardin Tiki on Sherbrooke East out by the Big Owe. Food not so great, but fun to order drinks in the tiki mugs. Wife is a tiki nut so we go there about once a year.
ReplyDelete@Anonymous - cool that you mention Crickets, that used to be the Friday 5 a 7 watering hole with the bunch I worked with in the late 80's.
Also we used to go to Wings & Things in NDG, after playing intramural (Fake ID's, Div 3) hockey at Loyola arena on Saturdays, back in the days when our wives would come & watch. Remember those giant beer mugs, just the ticket after a strenuous game.
Finally a recent loss: Diogenes on Decarie in St-Laurent near the Metro: In my opinion they had the best souvlaki and tzatziki in Montreal, but I suppose they were too far from downtown to make an impact in those annual 'Best of Montreal' listings.
How about the Eldorado Cafe on St
ReplyDeleteCathrine near St Laurent you could have a complete meal for about two bucks.. it was opened untill at least 1983 then a tattoo joint opened there...its a sex shop now... does anyone remember the name of the italian
resturant on peel near cypress that was upstairs? it was there for a long time...
The previous poster just reminded me of a great souvlaki place called The Four Seasons on the east side of Decarie Blvd. in Ville St. Laurent right across the street from the bank on the west side at 1000 Decarie.
ReplyDeleteThat restaurant closed sometime in the early '90s and was not affiliated with the hotel of the same name.
Curious about Ruby Foo's. That was the first place that broke the $15 barrier when I took my girlfriend - now my wife- to dinned. That was $15 for two!!!!! However upstairs in the Starlight Room the drinks were cheap and the cover was minimal. It was the fifties and their regular entertainment included Josh White, Kaye Ballard and many others.
ReplyDeleteOn a Montreal visit a number of years Hy's SteakHouse from Vancouver was operating the restaurant.
Re cafeterias didn't the Northeastern Lunch chain serve automat style?
The Select, on St-Denis/Ste. Cath is featured in several Michel Tremblay novels. I used to love to eat a grilled cheese sandwich there before catching the double feature at the Berri Theatre.
ReplyDeleteJust the other day, I was saying to my husband that if my grandmother came back from the dead (she passed away in 1978) she wouldn't recognize anything on Ste. Cath, either east or west of the Main, besides The Bay.
I do miss the old "quinze cennes" food counters at Woolworth, Kresge, etc.
It would be interesting to make a list of the few stores and restaurants downtown that were open back in 1982 and are still in existence.
I'm pretty lame because I can only think of The Bay, Reuben's and Dunn's!
I'm lovin' this thread.
ReplyDeleteSomeone mentioned the original Dagwood's at Laurentian and Cote Vertu. Of course, decades before Ben and Jerry's (and the "Swenson's" in the Capital Centre on Saint Catherine, remember that?) there was an ice cream place at Laurentian and Cote Vertu called Saint Aubin's, with a huge selection of crazy flavours. (My fave as a kid was the bubble gum flavour).
Anyone else go there? Have I spelled the name right?
Yes Dagwood's was great and the upstairs supper club with big band - it could have been Blake Sewell or Johnny Holmes or Paul Beauregard.
DeleteYes, I went to Swensons Ice Cream Parlor.
DeleteMy parents took us to Saint Aubin often. In "those" days it was a major expedition by car from NDG.
DeleteYes Shawn ... I remember St.Aubin ice cream We lived in St-Laurent and our family went there frequently.. pistachio chocolate rum & raisin —- yummm great memories.
DeleteMy top 3 favourites now sadly long gone....
ReplyDeleteMother Martin's - the best onion soup on earth
Le Coin - underneath Place Ville Marie - gigantic Martini's/Manhattan's and the best Julienne Salad with gorgeous creamy dressing going
Cafe Martin in the rue de la Montagne - Pure French elegance deluxe!
You mean... "La Mere Michel", not Mother Martin's. lol.
Delete....and also
ReplyDeleteLe Bon Vivant - in the Mount Royal Hotel - Prime Rib roast beef fit for the King.
The Picadilly - also in the Mount Royal Hotel - an "English" alternative to the Kon Tiki - the Chef served delicious hot hors d'oeuvres from a silver salvo trolley which went round and round during cocktail hour
La Picholette - in rue St. Denis housed in an old Victorian Mansion served good French classics - the Fondue Bruxelloise is a fond memory
Pam Pam - coffee house in Stanley Street, served European coffees, pastries and Hungarian goulashes, it was dark and edgy
@ Urban Legend The Four Seasons was owned by Tommy. Ate there in the early 80's twice a week. One day I brought a co-worker for the first time,who happened to be going to Florida the following week , near where was Tommy was going. They got together with their families over dinner , Tommy was insistent on picking up the tab. Nice guy , always with a smile.
ReplyDeleteI remember St. Aubin, it was where the Marcello`s (formerly Boccacinos) is now. It probably closed around 1980.
ReplyDeleteDecarie Fish & Chips is another that should come back... Unfortunately, now that most affordable fish is from China, it probably won`t happen in our lifetime. I understand it was originally on Decarie, then Acadie/Jean Talon. I used to go with my dad as a kid, they served the F&C on newspaper, great stuff!
mtl_bcer, Diogenes was a sad, sad loss for the area. I wonder if any of them are elsewhere cooking that wonderful souvlaki & doner.
Dankoff's on Peel north of Ste-Catherine, west side...The King of Pizza on Sherbrooke east of Grand...L'Habitant Steerburger (Ste-Catherine opposite Simpsons, La Cite, Sherbrooke W at Northcliffe) and not connected with Steerburger on Ste-Catherine run by Jimmy Gaspar...A&W Coffee Shops with tabel service (Decarie at Queen Mary, now the Tim Hortons/Wendy's, and 20 West of Dorval Circle)...on the West Island -- Terrasse Dorval in Dorval Gardens Shopping Centre (now Scores)...China House on St-Charles in Kirkland...Place Tevere's outlet in Fairview, as well as Woolworth's counter and adjacent Harvest House Cafeteria...the cafeteria at Eaton's Fairview, home of the Viking Burger...the counter at the Fairview Pharmacy Coffee Shop...Galleo's in the K-Mart Plaza (now Zeller's,soon-to-be Target)...Florentin at 225 Hymus next to Allied Chemical (now Future Electronics at 237) and now an Indian restaurant...the Beacon on Beaconsfield Blvd in Beaurepaire Village...New Ste-Anne's Sweets on the main drag in Ste-Anne-de-Bellevue, run by the Ferendinos Family...Pointe-Claire BBQ first on Cartier and then on de Lourdes in PC...
ReplyDeleteDANKOFF’s was the best!! I should know!! Marvin Dankoff
DeleteSt. Aubin ice cream closed later, 85-86. Also in St. Laurent, both on Decarie, was the China Inn and a snack bar simply called Spruce Beer.
ReplyDeleteI grew up in a house behind Decarie Fish & Chips. Used to go there often for their 15 cent fries and 20 cent fish (30 cents if both bought together). Also liked their 7 cent bottled soft drinks from the big box cooler filled with ice water.
ReplyDeleteNever worried about salt, fat, or mercury in those days.
Decarie Fish and Chips, owned by the Vitas Family, brings back such good memories. Best fish west of Newfoundland! In my time (1945-1960ish) 27 cents would buy you the tastiest plate of fish & chips and an Orange Crush drink in a brown bottle. Large plate of fish and chips was 25 cents. Every Friday the school kids would all crowd in there for lunch. I felt so denied because I was only allowed to go once per month.
DeleteJeez, this is getting deep.
ReplyDeleteNow that Wayne has brought the West Island solidly into the mix, I submit Rudy's BBQ on Sources Road in DDO.
It was pretty much the same as St-Hubert, but it was a DDO institution and kinda considered cool, as I recall.
Wayne, if you're seeing this, where were the Woolworth's/Harvest House Caf and Place Tevere, in Fairview Mall? I'm drawing a blank on that, and we lived out there before the mall was even built.
My father is Rudy! He's 82 now and still talks about the BBQ. He started off as a dishwasher and clean up guy at Al's Soda Bar and worked his way to his own restaurant:)
DeleteI was a West Island boy. Rudys could keep up with St.Hubert flavour wise. Also Mamma Bears( I think) Fried chicken at Sources & Pierrefonds Boulevard which was there before KFC. Harvest House Cafe in Fairview was on the main promenade in Fairview beside Pascals. There was also a deli in the side promenade beside Steinbergs. Place Tevere was pizza place off Gouin I believe.
DeleteOh, one more: for some reason, my dad was obsessed with Broadway Chips out in Montreal East.
ReplyDeleteThere's still a storefront with Broadway on it, out that way, but it's no longer a chip haven -- or much of anything.
I also was obsessed with Broadway chips. I was the only person I knew who would trek all the way out there (east) from NDG.
DeleteI remember Rudy's BBQ on Sources in Dollard as a child - for some reason the finger bowls with lemon slices in the warm water facinated me when I was six!
ReplyDeleteI miss several old-school Chinese restaurants that are now gone.
ReplyDeleteThe Dragon House in Cartierville, which IMO had the best pineapple chicken, chicken fried rice, egg-rolls and plum sauce in the city!
I also morn the loss of legendary The Yangtze on Van Horne (which burned down in December) and Tchang Kiang in NDG (which closed down in July). Sadly the new restaurant that tried to resurrect and merge both under one roof is a complete joke, not even worth ranting about.
I also miss the Brown Derby, I last remember going there with my family, after my high school graduation ceremony. Used to go there a lot in my childhood too.
I was just thinking how there are no worthwhile restaurants are left in Montreal. Apart from Chalet BBQ in NDG, I can't think of any others I'd miss if I left the city and province for good.
Snowdon Deli on Decarie/Isabella is still chugging along quite nicely...
ReplyDeleteHouse of Wong around the corner on Queen Mary is gone. Lived on their "#2 for 1" while I crammed through my college years.
Despite what is sadly missed, we can still be thankful about the superior quality of food served in Montreal's restaurants.
ReplyDeleteYou would think that ANY city with their various ethnic traditions in food preparation and style would give us a run for out money, but not so. Go figure!
True, a lot of it may have something to do with certain specific recipes and ingredients not available elsewhere, or perhaps even to our relatively stringent health laws regarding restaurant kitchens.
Montreal just seems to have that savoir faire.
Just a few old spots that I miss:
ReplyDelete1) Chateau BBQ: on Sherbrooke at Grey(?)- it's the spot where Bureau en Gros is now.
2) Ben Ash on Ste.Catherine & St.Laurent -Northeast corner
3) Pumpernik's: on Decarie just north of Queen Mary Great grub in sometimes gross volume.
4&5) Vito's on Cotes Des Neiges near Lacombe and Peppe's upstairs on Peel opposite Dominion Square: Both were my introduction to Italian cooking that wasn't smothered in cheese and pasta.
6) Benny's: A delicatessen on Park Ave. just south of Bernard. I hated going in there as a kid: Going past the cash always meant a pinch on the cheek from "Mrs.Benny". But the food was good.
7) Balkan's: First on Bleury between Ste.Catherine & DeMaisonneuve, then on President Kennedy just west of Bleury. Plain old-fashioned Jewish cooking. Very plain.
8) The Turf on Ste Catherine & Bleury SW corner. It wasn't a lunch counter in a drugstore, but the space was half restaurant half drugstore. Used to regularly go there before shows at PdA.
9) (Last one): The Happy Wanderer, a Swiss place on Ste.Catherine between St.Marc & Tower.
Good food, and one of the nicest restaurant experiences I ever had happened there:
An old man got up and asked for the bill. Waitress gently but firmly explained to him that he'd already paid and sent him on his way. I later found out he was retired, quite low on money,down on his heels, and a little senile. He'd go to the Wanderer every month or so, after the pension cheques came in, but Wanderer never let him pay, because he was a nice fellow, and just down on his luck, so why not just let him retain his dignity, and feed him at the same time??
lots of great resto names of yesterday, we need a museum
ReplyDeleteAh, the Snowdon Del. Believe it or not, I only just discovered a few months ago what a good smoked meat sandwich they serve! I've had cold-cut smoked meat from them for years, don't know how I never got around to eating a hot sandwich at the restaurant (or if I did, it would've been as a kid growing up).
ReplyDeleteAlmost as good as Schwartz's used to be, but not quite (Schwartz today, sadly, is just sorely disappointing).
Otherwise though, I think Montreal has lost its savoir faire for restaurants. It once was THE place for food, I find that not the case anymore.
Le Pickwick.
ReplyDeleteA pint-sized french restaurant in a basement on Drummond, it served excellent french fare for a pittance.
Closed around 1980.
Silly me.
ReplyDeleteHow could I forgot thed most magnificent restaurant ever, established in the bowels of the remainder of the most magnificent hotel ever to be established in the Empire, the Windsor hotel?
I am talking, of course, about "Le vaisseau d'or", founded by none other than his worship Jean Drapeau, a restaurant offeing such magnificent ambiance music that patrons were urged to refrain from talking whilst the music played...
One day, during contract negociations with the firemen's union, two firetrucks unloaded a squadron of booted firemen who then endeavoured to search "le vaisseau d'or" for some reportedly signaled smoke emanations...
The first pizza I ever had in my life was at Mama Mia Pizzeria in the 1960s in NDG and I still think it was the best. The only topping choices were green peppers, fresh mushrooms,pepperoni,cheese, and if you wanted to live on the wild side, anchovies.
ReplyDeleteThe crust was slightly blackened on the bottom as were the edges of the pepperoni slices. You could pull the mozzerella cheese to about 18 inches.
A large pizza meant a large pizza. About 2-1/2 feet wide. You had to hold a slice with two hands because it would fall over in one hand.
If you were really hungry you might even make an attempt at eating the dough ball in the middle of the pizza that was there to prevent the pizza from sticking to to top of the inside of the pizza box.
The only downer was a soft drink called Brio that they sold. Tasted like Coke with oregano.
Once in Seattle and once in Sausalito in California I tasted a pizza that was similar to Mama Mia. I still think that if it isn't Italians making the pizza it really isn't pizza.
Ham and pineapple? There are no pineapples in Italy.
Colin Paterson-Vancouver Island
the chinese resto on St-Katherine near corner of Guy that was eaten up by the mcdo that opened there. I had my first and still best Ma Po Tofu there and I miss it to this day!
ReplyDeleteI'm back.
ReplyDeleteMoon Wah on the west side of Phillips Square. What's that street called- Union?
New Lotus on Lagoshitthere.
Last time I was in Mama Mia's, we came out after lunch just in time to see some poor guy get run over by a truck. His head squished open! We almost made it back to West Hill before puking our guts out.
That was 1965 or '66.
Went through a period of weekly visits to the restaurant up in hotel Bonaventure (across the aisle from the duck pond up there. My mom & I both developed an addiction for their vichysoisse.
(Or however you spell that.)
Continental/Soupiere on Mountain (not Montagne) St. Phenomenal mixed grill.
Crepe Bretonne on St.Denis, just south of St.Louis Sq. Crepe, sausages, bechamel sauce. Mmmm.
Ever realise that is you say "Jesus" backwards, it sounds like sausage?
In the late forties, early fifties, my parents liked the Queen's Hotel dining room for major family events.Nice room, good food AND a strolling violinist.
ReplyDeleteAround 1969, we students would go to "MacDonald's" (not "Mc") on St. Catherine across from Eatons - where you could get 5 burgers for a buck.
ReplyDeleteWhen I started working a couple of years later, one of my regular stops was the St. Lawrence Cafeteria in Place Ville Marie (where Reitman's and Renaud-Bray are now).
You can still get a good nourishing cafeteria meal at any of the large hospitals.
Someone's already mentioned it, but Cafe Martin on Mountain Street gets my vote. Of course the best tables were in the bar downstairs. And, yeah, any Murray's. And Macy's drugstore/tea room, corner of Victoria and Sherbrooke in Westmount. Made their Cokes from syrup. Cherry Cokes, too. Mother Martin's on St-Antoine. Eaton's dining room--what can I say, I'm mtl anglo. Grumpy scotch (not scots) waitresses at Ogilvy's.
ReplyDeleteA few pretty venerable (and good) places that I think are still around:
ReplyDelete-Magnan's on St.Patrick at Charlevoix
-Elio on Bellechasse, couple blocks east of St.Denis. I've never found a more magnificent pizza.
-Mr.Steer on Ste.Catherine at Drummond (I first went there in '67/''68).
-Lester's Deli on Bernard near Hutchison.
-Mommy's fish and chips on Notre Dame near 32nd in Lachine.
A place that's gone but missed: "Il Etait Un Fois", a retro-themed hamburger (and little else) place just off McGill across from the Customs building. It was in an abandoned and refurbished Grand Trunk Railway station. Great burgers, cherry Coke, stuff like that.
Okay, I'm done with the subject now- I promise!
That station building on McGill St. was actually the terminus for the Montreal and Southern Counties Railway, which ran across the Victoria Bridge out towards Granby (until 1956). The building has had several reincarnations over the years.
ReplyDeleteanyone remember the George salad w/avocado dressing at the Continental restaurant on Mountain,during the 60's and 70's? if so, anyone have or duplicate the recipe ?
ReplyDeleteprobably one of the best salads i have ever eaten !!!
What a trip down memory lane! Let me add a few:
ReplyDeleteas a Greek, I'd be remiss if I didn't mention Salona souvlaki on Park near Fairmount. There was also a Zorba souvlaki on St-Viateur I believe east of Park. My bros and I ate at these places when we worked at my dad's printing shop on Park, next to Hollywood Cafe and Champion billiards.
There was also the Kentucky Fried Chicken on Park near Fairmount that was there as long as I remember till it closed maybe 5 years ago?
As very young kids, we lived upstairs from Zita Restaurant on Park near where Mythos is now "At Zita restaurant, you will eat like Gods!'
There was also Mykonos Sherbrooke west of Decarie, for whom Don McGowan did TV ads. There was Ma Heller's in that same neighbourhood, owned by a family friend at the time, late 70s early 80s.
Back on Park, there was Dusty's off Mt. Royal, reputed for their breakfast. I recall their sign out front was "Dusty" all the way to the right and "'s" wrapped on the left (special for the language gestapo no doubt).
Arcade restaurant on St-Cath, I believe west of McGill College near the old Palace cinema. Somebody mentioned the Turf. My dad did printing for all these places. Also Forsom steak house inside the Chateau Champlain.
Palais Montcalm, a good family friend, still going strong, but it used to be on the north side of Ontario, more west, close to the market. A smaller store back in the day, although, still very busy.
I remember delivering to a place called Dominique(?) on St.Cath just east of St.Lawrence, south side.
We went to Swenson's a couple of times in the 80s after a movie downtown. There was also a short lived fast food chain called Frits.
In suburbia, I remember Diogenes, great souvlaki and classy dining room considering the fast food street. We spent many a quarter (and hour) at Fonzie's arcade. Spruce Beer was popular there too, as was Four Seasons. Thanasi was a good family friend, he has passed on some 5 years or so now. His wife was a good friend of my mom's, classy lady, she owned a store selling high end children's clothing and accessories, great people.
Marco Polo on Cote-Ste-Cath near Queen Mary made excellent pizza. My brother ate their every week.
Dragon House in that strip mall near the end of Salaberry west, wow, that place was open even before we moved into the neighbourhood in '82 and went strong till about maybe 10 years ago. I got my hair cut at George the Greek right next door for close to 15 years.
I wonder if anybody remembers Lentzos resto on the south side of Beaubien, on a corner, a few blocks west of Papineau. My late uncle owned it late 70s and throughout the 80s, and we ate there every week. Great subs and pizza, and even better memories!
I watched this on The CTV news today and was very surprised there was no mention of Murray's...My mother worked at the Laurentian Hotel restaurant for over 25 years....I worked at the one on St. Catherine St. for 5 years....The food was absolutely delicious!!! So sad when I heard the last one had closed!!! The end of an era!!!!
ReplyDeleteAnyone knows the name of the seafood restaurant located on 1515 Ste-Catherine until the mid-80's The location is ocupied by Concordia Engineering Building now-in front of Pharmaprix. They serverd great food and had good ambiance.
ReplyDeleteLikely wrong one... not sure where this one was located, but just maybe: Pavillon d'Atlantique? Loved that place. Pricey but worth it.
DeleteI guess you're talking about Lentzos. Yeah that was pretty cool. Kitty corner from a weird crusty doughnut shop where The Great Antonio hung out.
ReplyDeleteDarn, I don't remember the doughnut shop, but I do recall seeing the Great Antonio either at the restaurant or in the neighbourhood.
ReplyDeleteThe restaurant now is Chez Billy
@WU MICHAEL The seafood place was called Chez Pauze.
ReplyDeleteDoes anybody remember the Italian restaurant that was on the corner of Jean Talon and de la Savanne?? I think it is currently Abe and Mary's.
ReplyDeleteHow about Rymark's Tavern on Peel Street. A big Pig's knuckle washed down with a couple of quarts.
ReplyDeleteTim Q.
Mama Mia's on Sherbrooke in NDG -- absolutely the best pizza -- my nighttime meal for several years when I was going to Loyola, the Golden Hind in the QE Hotel had great roast beef and hot german potato salad and gin martinis that I follow the recipe for to this day. If I had a dollar for every martini -- WOW. Gerty's (early 70s) in the concourse of PVM had wonderful gazpacho.
ReplyDeleteMother Martin's onion soup at lunch was all you needed until the next day. And lastly, Au Cepage, a french bistro menu that started next door to the Montreal Star building and closed in the late 90s at the Notre Dame corner of St. Francis Xavier last location. Great camaraderie and a foxy bartender!
Here are some of my favs:
ReplyDeleteGerty's in the concourse at PVM -- great gazpacho (early 70s)
Mother Martin's onion soup -- all one needed from lunch to the next day.
Paesano's on Cote des Neiges -- ate there every Sunday in the Fall after playing football for College Notre Dame (early 60s).
The Golden Hind in the QE hotel -- great Roast Beef with hot german potato salad and Beefeater martinis that I still use the recipe for to this day. If I had a dollar for every one -- WOW
Last, Au Cepage, a french bistro menu. Its beginning was next to the Montreal Star building, when it closed in the late 90s, it had moved to Notre Dame X St. Francis Xavier -- good food, good camaraderie, and a foxy bartender!
ReplyDeleteI don't see the Limelight mentioned. It was actually a coffee house but also had light meals. It was on Pierce Street and had fabulous baklava. As well, there was the Tartan Room on top of Ogilvy's. Is that still alive? What a treat to see all these names again. I must mention that I once attended a kid's birthday party at Ruby Foo's and watched Magic Tom take an egg out of a child's ear. Or was it a silver dollar? Hmmmm.
Le Lutèce was a nice little place on DeMaisonneuve, and Chez George had the best Vychissoise I ever ate. Then there was Carmen Chez George on Stanley... next to William Tell. Ah, the Good Old Days!
ReplyDeleteThe Pu-Pu platter at Pumpernick's with the flaming mini hibachi in the middle to reheat the different appetizers was my favorite. Their coleslaw was the perfect sweet garlic deli style.
ReplyDeleteBar-B-Barn's ribs and frozen crinkle cut fries were incredible. The 7 vegetable salad amazing. The Spanish rice forgettable.
Sun Sun Café on Clark
Two restos I can't remember the names of: A big barn of a place on St-Laurent above Jarry Park (1960s?) that served Québec cuisine and had mis-matched pine tables and chairs. Barnwood façade. Tourtieres and maple sypup pie type-deal. And a tiny, 4-5 tables Belgian lunch place - 1950s! - east side opposite Simpson's, below "Burnside", my first taste of rabbit and other fare was there. The old lady ran the place alone.
ReplyDeleteThe "big barn of a place" on St-Laurent was, first, a tavern and, then, a brasserie called Le Gobelet.
DeleteLes Carbinniers or The Carb, Atwater Metro level, men only tavern in 1974 3 12oz beer for a buck tip included
ReplyDeleteJoes Steak House downtown, great steaks for $5 with all the trimmings and you would always see a Montreal celeb like Don McGowan or an athlete.
Only one person mentioned Il Etait Un Fois. I absolutely adored their burgers...huge thick and juicy. Great flavor. It was a trek to get there but I would not eat anything all day so I would be hungry enough to eat two of those whopping burgers and wash them own with an old fashioned cherry coke. This place was the best.
ReplyDeleteDunns downtown served up a burger using that same recipe...but it wasn't quite the same.
Old post that I just happened upon, but had to mention Franni's on Monkland should be revived. Best Swiss chocolate almond cheesecake ever...among others.
ReplyDeleteI live in Alberta but was born and raised in Montreal. My friend hooked me up with a great dentist on Queen Mary Road. After the appointment, I was always so hungry. So I discovered a place called Pumpernicks. Of course I had a frozen mouth. Ordered a chicken salad sandwich on a bun with fries and coleslaw. OMG! so delicious, frozen mouth and all. I went there every dentist appointment!
ReplyDeleteThere was Chez Pierre on the south side of Ste. Catherine East. It was owned by a chef from France who had been the chef for a European leaders conference in Paris (that led up to World War 1). The silk menu for that conference hung on the wall.
ReplyDeleteThe best smoked meat in Montreal was at a small place in Norgate Shopping Centre in St. Laurent. I can't remember the name of it. Might have been the Curly Q.
There was another favoured spot for a meal and some wine - and one whose name I have forgotten. Café Andre?
The first Japanese restaurant, I think, was Tokyo Sukyaki - which was a great experience. You sat in your own screened dining room on a cushion, your feet hanging down through a hole in the floor, and with the table top at floor level. A charming waitress knelt to take your shoes off, and again to put them on when you left. (If you were a man.) Women were on their own.
Mind you. Even at it's best, Montreal was never as good as Moncton. We have MacDonald's and Tim Horton's and everything.
Graeme Decarie
Café André is correct
DeleteWoolworths on Ste Catherine.
ReplyDeleteSigh... I do miss Spruce Beer on Decarie so. I literally grew up there, my family choosing there over Decarie Hot Dog just down the street. It's where I grew to love my burgers and dogs "all dressed", spruce beer, and where I ate my first poutine. All this despite the signed picture of local boy/enemy/Bruins Raymond Bourque. Chris and the boys always treated us marvellously. It was literally one thing I missed the most when we moved to Toronto in '89.
ReplyDeleteThey closed the Arcade tavern on st. antoine (or maybe were displaced cuz of hwy or Mr and Mrs. Andrews were too old?) and opened up the Arcade Restaurant at 1188 Ste-Cath West. my grandmother said they did "goofballs" at the tavern. people from rockhead's went to the restaurant also.
ReplyDeleteThere was the bbque chicken restaurant on st-catherine east near UQAM near St-Denis called Au Poulet Dore. This was the best barbecue chicken ever with salted mushrooms (mashed,baked or french fries potatoes), their gravy was a knock out...with a glass of white wine and to polish it all off coconut cream pie to die for!
ReplyDeleteThere also was a Lentzo's restaurant located in Plattsburgh, N.Y.
Does anyone remember the name of the hungarian lady with black hair and false eye lashes at the Pam Pam room on Stanley st? Best hungarian coffee and pastries. (besides the coffee mill on Moutain st).
Across the street was a pizza place now gone... Das Pasquale? all of these places are now gone. :((
The Naffy, McGill College near Sherbrooke. Mistake to go for the food. Mistake to go for then ambience. Memorable nonetheless.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeletename of restaurant yhat took your picture with a little (live) pig,that
was pushed around to you table on a trolley ! 1950's plus ?
There was a restaurant that a little piglet was being fed from a milk bottle. I saw a photo a couple of weeks ago.
ReplyDeleteDid anyone mention The Place For Steak on the 2 and 20 (now just the 20), which is now a parking lot for the train--just east of St. John's.
ReplyDeleteThe William Tell. The McGill sandwich shop on Prince Arthur.
ReplyDeleteWhere was "The Place for Steak"?
ReplyDeleteJoe Beef Joe's Steak House or Moishe's?
ReplyDeleteI worked as a busboy at Mother Martin's, 900 St. Antoine, Expo year (1967) with Abby Fink (waiter). Visited many times with my Dad and Mom and later proposed to my wife there. Best dish . . . Lobster Thermidor.
ReplyDeleteLooking for an Italian restaurent on decarie mama Tomassi tks great souvenirs and great food
ReplyDelete