I contributed to the Montreal Mirror from 1986 to 2006, including a few years as city columnist and a news writing staffer.
My view is that it died not just because of the internet thing but because it just got tired and lost its passion and appetite for risk. Here's my entirely-biased take on my association with the paper.
My view is that it died not just because of the internet thing but because it just got tired and lost its passion and appetite for risk. Here's my entirely-biased take on my association with the paper.
It began when I called up the Montreal Mirror out of the blue on my pushbutton Vista phone from my $125 downtown apartment one day in October 1987. I was a 23-year-old History grad from McGill working at Bell Canada.
Brendan Weston answered. He had moved into the news editor role from the bully pulpit of the McGill Daily, a skittish kid with Billy Idol hair and whose mom reported for Pulse News.
I told him that I had written articles for local newspapers since I was 16 and wanted to write something, anything. He sent me to cover some sort of garbage management meeting, then some outrageous plan for Ahuntsic Park.
I was surprised to get 40 bucks per article; it fed my ongoing addiction to earning money from writing.
The Mirror office at that time overlooked St. Catherine across from The Spectrum.*
Kindly editor Martin Siberok told tell me to leave only one space after a period. Computers were still pretty new.
The office then moved to first-floor digs in an old building near the bottom of McGill Street. Owners Eyal and Catherine had a way-too-large office at the end. Eyal looked grumpy but was in fact, a disarmingly friendly Iraqi Jew. Catherine was unapproachable.
Albert Nerenberg had been writing some insane stuff for the paper, including one about The Blob, which Douglas Coupland would later re-dub Generation X. I liked his crazy passion, I sniffed some creativity happening there.
I asked Eyal about selling ads once or twice. He said sure but I never did. It would have been far more lucrative, but I stupidly stuck to freelancing news.
After Brendan left I concentrated on my MA. I’d pick it up occasionally and noticed someone named Eleanor Brown, apparently a very nice person, writing ferocious pro-feminist articles. And people like Christina Stockwood would write big features with ledes such as “Prime Minister Brian Mulroney proved himself to be a lap-dog of the Americans once again …”
It didn't seem like my kind of publication any more.
Sometime during that period, I brought in a story I had been working on about a bizarre woman I had interviewed who hoped to personally persuade the authorities to legalize prostitution. The hooker was stark raving mad but I managed to frame the article in some useful overviews and other academic perspective.
I brought it in and got icy stares from Karen Herland or whoever was there. No go.
I then sold same the article to MTL magazine for a lofty $300. I had introduced myself to Alastair Sutherland, the editor, by cold-calling him at home and telling him that I'm the best freelance writer in Montreal. He ran a few more of my pieces and we became friends.
Soon after, Peter Scowen began editing the Mirror. He grew up a few blocks from me on Landsdowne in Westmount but I didn’t know him. He had apparently edited some paper in the Townships and his father, of course, was a prominent longtime Liberal MNA.
People complained that Scowen was unknowable but he seemed normal to me. I didn’t spend much time in the office but it seemed full of entertaining gossip, two editors caught smooching at a desk and so forth. It reached its height of absurdity when Jake Richler was brought in to pen a column but he didn’t last long as he just sent in humourless right wing screeds.
Around that time I wrote a feature scrutinizing psychic Jojo Savard, which was published while I was traveling in India. News editor Chris Sheridan liked it so much he made sure it got nominated it for some kid of journalism award. I was pretty happy about his support.
In 1993, I wrote a story about white slavery in a strip club near where I lived, which the news editor by now Patricia Bush, was so keen on that she added her own interviews to. The article was as smash hit and really put the Mirror onto lips around the city. I overheard people talking about it on the Ste. Catherine.
By this time MTL magazine had gone belly up and I spent hours drinking and playing tennis with its former editor Alastair. He got work doing proofreading at the Mirror. Scowen moved to Toronto and Sutherland took over.
Columnist Josh Bezonsky left to move to Toronto, so I took that over. The pressure was high because Hour was all fired up and trying to take over the alt weekly market now under the leadership of Scowen, who had made the switch over to the upstart, which was launched after owners spurned offers from Voir to buy the publication.
Brendan Weston answered. He had moved into the news editor role from the bully pulpit of the McGill Daily, a skittish kid with Billy Idol hair and whose mom reported for Pulse News.
I told him that I had written articles for local newspapers since I was 16 and wanted to write something, anything. He sent me to cover some sort of garbage management meeting, then some outrageous plan for Ahuntsic Park.
The Mirror office at that time overlooked St. Catherine across from The Spectrum.*
Kindly editor Martin Siberok told tell me to leave only one space after a period. Computers were still pretty new.
The office then moved to first-floor digs in an old building near the bottom of McGill Street. Owners Eyal and Catherine had a way-too-large office at the end. Eyal looked grumpy but was in fact, a disarmingly friendly Iraqi Jew. Catherine was unapproachable.
Albert Nerenberg had been writing some insane stuff for the paper, including one about The Blob, which Douglas Coupland would later re-dub Generation X. I liked his crazy passion, I sniffed some creativity happening there.
I asked Eyal about selling ads once or twice. He said sure but I never did. It would have been far more lucrative, but I stupidly stuck to freelancing news.After Brendan left I concentrated on my MA. I’d pick it up occasionally and noticed someone named Eleanor Brown, apparently a very nice person, writing ferocious pro-feminist articles. And people like Christina Stockwood would write big features with ledes such as “Prime Minister Brian Mulroney proved himself to be a lap-dog of the Americans once again …”
It didn't seem like my kind of publication any more.
Sometime during that period, I brought in a story I had been working on about a bizarre woman I had interviewed who hoped to personally persuade the authorities to legalize prostitution. The hooker was stark raving mad but I managed to frame the article in some useful overviews and other academic perspective.
I brought it in and got icy stares from Karen Herland or whoever was there. No go.
I then sold same the article to MTL magazine for a lofty $300. I had introduced myself to Alastair Sutherland, the editor, by cold-calling him at home and telling him that I'm the best freelance writer in Montreal. He ran a few more of my pieces and we became friends.
Soon after, Peter Scowen began editing the Mirror. He grew up a few blocks from me on Landsdowne in Westmount but I didn’t know him. He had apparently edited some paper in the Townships and his father, of course, was a prominent longtime Liberal MNA.
People complained that Scowen was unknowable but he seemed normal to me. I didn’t spend much time in the office but it seemed full of entertaining gossip, two editors caught smooching at a desk and so forth. It reached its height of absurdity when Jake Richler was brought in to pen a column but he didn’t last long as he just sent in humourless right wing screeds.
Around that time I wrote a feature scrutinizing psychic Jojo Savard, which was published while I was traveling in India. News editor Chris Sheridan liked it so much he made sure it got nominated it for some kid of journalism award. I was pretty happy about his support.
In 1993, I wrote a story about white slavery in a strip club near where I lived, which the news editor by now Patricia Bush, was so keen on that she added her own interviews to. The article was as smash hit and really put the Mirror onto lips around the city. I overheard people talking about it on the Ste. Catherine.
By this time MTL magazine had gone belly up and I spent hours drinking and playing tennis with its former editor Alastair. He got work doing proofreading at the Mirror. Scowen moved to Toronto and Sutherland took over.
Columnist Josh Bezonsky left to move to Toronto, so I took that over. The pressure was high because Hour was all fired up and trying to take over the alt weekly market now under the leadership of Scowen, who had made the switch over to the upstart, which was launched after owners spurned offers from Voir to buy the publication.
The Mirror countered with its own French publication called Ici, which never really took off and was pretty quickly put out of its misery.
Some of my columns were pretty dreadful at the start but it was through no lack of effort, I’d wear out my phone, ringing up any and everybody with questions. There was no stopping me, I’d be quite rude and demanding and cajoling, whatever required to score something fresh that nobody else was doing.
I would pick up the phone book and call one association after another to see if I could get scuttlebutt or an idea. Hello Blind Association, I'm calling to talk to whoever talks to journalists, I want to know what you people are up to, what can you tell me?
Often the people I called had no idea what Montreal Mirror was. But meanwhile there were readers and aspiring writers who held the publication in strangely high esteem and seemed to know my work better than myself.
The paper would publish any old ad hominen attack in its letters to the editor section. Once I described something as being “as hot as a crack pipe on welfare day.” People got a chuckle about it but some outraged character wrote to complain.
One letter suggested that I should get hit on the head with a vodka bottle. They published it.
My philosophy towards writing: I imagine myself in a bar at a table full of a dozen drunken friends. I stand up and try to make a little speech. That speech is my article. Their attention span is about half a second so I’ve got to really make it good. That’s what an article has to be. Not just interesting, but crazy interesting, funny as hell, desperate, educational and maybe a little naughty or dangerous if possible.
One time I saw a story about four teenage girls on trial for assault for beating up Quebec rock star Serge Fiori. I was all over that story like peanut butter.
I revealed how Fiori’s psychologist described him and his girlfriend as lunatics and how the two had scored a pretty good sum from the victim’s compensation fund for the scuffle.
The story was a massive, boiling success, but by this time Quebecor had bought the paper (in 1996) and moved it into a sterile office building up the street.
I had a title as some kinda of editor but I just wrote articles and rarely edited anything. I worked from home and only attended the weekly meetings. I would drink with the guys but I was happy to be out of the office.
I had to work 50 weeks a year, so I stupidly tried to work through the construction holidays, insisting as always to get original content.
I’d call companies, beg, barter, yell at secretaries, berating them if necessary if they couldn’t find someone to give me a comment.
I was so determined to root out original stories, even during dead times, that I occasionally scored a gem out of sheer willpower, such as the story that sparked the campaign to put the suicide-barriers on the Jacques Cartier Bridge.
Unfortunately one of my good friends Louis-Martin was one of the last to jump to his death from that bridge after I wrote that article and I still feel a bit guilty about writing it now.
Eventually I moved on and did more real estate, which paid much better. Many of the same faces were still there when it closed and I felt sad for them.
-
*The first offices were 408 St. James W., Suite 42, the second offices at 305 St. Catherine W., in August 1988 the paper moved to first floor at 400 McGill and stayed there for many years before moving across the street into the less-funky Quebecor offices.(Thanks to former employee Paul Etch for precise info).
Some of my columns were pretty dreadful at the start but it was through no lack of effort, I’d wear out my phone, ringing up any and everybody with questions. There was no stopping me, I’d be quite rude and demanding and cajoling, whatever required to score something fresh that nobody else was doing.
I would pick up the phone book and call one association after another to see if I could get scuttlebutt or an idea. Hello Blind Association, I'm calling to talk to whoever talks to journalists, I want to know what you people are up to, what can you tell me?
Often the people I called had no idea what Montreal Mirror was. But meanwhile there were readers and aspiring writers who held the publication in strangely high esteem and seemed to know my work better than myself.
The paper would publish any old ad hominen attack in its letters to the editor section. Once I described something as being “as hot as a crack pipe on welfare day.” People got a chuckle about it but some outraged character wrote to complain.
One letter suggested that I should get hit on the head with a vodka bottle. They published it.
My philosophy towards writing: I imagine myself in a bar at a table full of a dozen drunken friends. I stand up and try to make a little speech. That speech is my article. Their attention span is about half a second so I’ve got to really make it good. That’s what an article has to be. Not just interesting, but crazy interesting, funny as hell, desperate, educational and maybe a little naughty or dangerous if possible.
One time I saw a story about four teenage girls on trial for assault for beating up Quebec rock star Serge Fiori. I was all over that story like peanut butter.
I revealed how Fiori’s psychologist described him and his girlfriend as lunatics and how the two had scored a pretty good sum from the victim’s compensation fund for the scuffle.
The story was a massive, boiling success, but by this time Quebecor had bought the paper (in 1996) and moved it into a sterile office building up the street.
I had a title as some kinda of editor but I just wrote articles and rarely edited anything. I worked from home and only attended the weekly meetings. I would drink with the guys but I was happy to be out of the office.
I had to work 50 weeks a year, so I stupidly tried to work through the construction holidays, insisting as always to get original content.
I’d call companies, beg, barter, yell at secretaries, berating them if necessary if they couldn’t find someone to give me a comment.
I was so determined to root out original stories, even during dead times, that I occasionally scored a gem out of sheer willpower, such as the story that sparked the campaign to put the suicide-barriers on the Jacques Cartier Bridge.
Unfortunately one of my good friends Louis-Martin was one of the last to jump to his death from that bridge after I wrote that article and I still feel a bit guilty about writing it now.
Eventually I moved on and did more real estate, which paid much better. Many of the same faces were still there when it closed and I felt sad for them.
-
*The first offices were 408 St. James W., Suite 42, the second offices at 305 St. Catherine W., in August 1988 the paper moved to first floor at 400 McGill and stayed there for many years before moving across the street into the less-funky Quebecor offices.(Thanks to former employee Paul Etch for precise info).
Cool story, bro.
ReplyDeleteSounds like the time is ripe for a new weekly; perhaps between the two of them (hour and mirror), a few willing souls remian.
Captain Carl
You were the spirit of The Montreal Mirror!
ReplyDeleteYou have the material for a first rate novel, if not two or three. Don't let the opportunity pass. And your prose is exciting to read. I sense a Hemmingway ....... Go man go..!
ReplyDeleteMichael Fish
In the last 7-8 years I thinked I picked up the Mirror, uh, well I could count on my hands how many times.
ReplyDeleteIt just never changed. It was always the same stuff in the same order. It's like they gave up long ago but are just in it because they need to earn a paycheque, so to speak.
So yeah, we have great memories of the Mirror and since it shouldn't suffer anymore, it was rightfully put out of its misery.
I wasn't that worried about individual articles, or their impact on the world. Same time, I was surprised at how easily I was taken on. Don't think they read my sample articles. Writing art reviews didn't take the heavy-duty research that writing news did. Part of the reason I left (or was fired), was that I wasn't quite "edgy" enough, while still hewing to the requirements of writing about what they wanted me to.
ReplyDeleteI avoided the office at all costs.
Hi.. to the people whose comments were not approved, I welcome you to resubmit them a little more (in one case) on topic and (in the other) slightly less defamatory.
ReplyDeleteYour "Kristian Perspective" column was the main reason why I picked The Mirror fresh from the racks...
ReplyDeleteAnd I was once rewarded by an e-mail from you regarding some stuff about the Métro and my Métro website.
W's was a bit too risque and personal, although it was a great story. E's was off-topic.
ReplyDeleteLooks like your fans and haters are back to know what,s happenin? I was an avid reader of the Mirror during those years you were penning articles but haven't read it in 10 years as I moved away. I loved your articles, the specials as well as the nightlife updates. Kept me informed in the pre-Internet days : ) Im still surprised it cant survive, being free and available everywhere.
ReplyDeleteOK, I will only repost that story when the Hotel de la Montagne finally gets demolished as there is more of a connection in that regard than in this city vignette.
ReplyDeleteIt's a shame Québecor closed the paper without allowing a final goodbye issue. The paper deserved a better end, it had some history and still had some personality.
ReplyDeleteI have no fond memories of the Mirror. Talking to a customer (who worked there) one day, I wondered how our store was always voted third "best of Montreal" in our category. He said if we advertised in the rag our rating would go up. Suggested I talk to some specific "elitist hipster" whose name I've long since forgotten. Big deal. True or not, I'll pass.
ReplyDeleteIt was a three year battle to get circulation to stop scattering the weekly pile of newspaper garbage all over the entranceway and sidewalk in front of the store instead of leaving it bundled.
Good riddance anyways, even if the demise comes 15 years later than it should have. For us at least, it was nothing more than an annoyance.
Bookmonger, you got me going regarding the endless parade of junk material tossed randomly all over the place--particularly in and around mailboxes, such as those dull suburban "newspapers", circulars, catalogues, coupons, menus, tax service touts of questionable competence, religious tracts, and the like. Indeed, much of the trash floating around on our streets and lawns is exactly that, and something the City of Montreal is trying to curtail.
ReplyDeleteOne of the worst offenders is Publisac which evidently could care less when attaching their plastic bags of circulars to the residential doorknobs of those who could very well be away on vacation--a dead giveaway (pun unintentional but appropriate!) to burglars.
In fact, I once remember a media story many years ago where Publisac and its competitors were specifically not to do this, but they continue to do it anyway.
I am constantly seeing legions of dull-witted bozos throwing masses of this rubbish into buildings and then running off around the block to meet the next truckload. It's no use catching them in the act and confronting them, either, as they'll just drop it in the vestibule and scurry away like rats unless you are fortunate enough to live in a building with a doorman who can give them the bum's rush.
Placing "no junk mail" stickers on or near your mailbox is also blatantly ignored by Canada Post's mail carriers as well. I can only assume that Canada Post has ordered its employees to pay no attention to "no junk mail" notices, and even even moreso now that email has made significant inroads to personal messages and billing.
Another unsightly blight is the insistance by certain advertisers to indiscriminately plaster any available blank wall with their posters announcing various upcoming events, all of which in my opinion is essentially unwanted "printed graffiti". And it seemingly isn't enough to place ONE large poster. No, they need to jam in as many as they can possibly fit! Surely it is no secret exactly WHO is responsible for this "poster mess"?
I remember once seeing a city employee vigorously scraping off some of these posters from a wall, so I asked him why the city doesn't simply SUE the perpetrators and thus put a stop to it once and for all, and he agreed that it was a good idea! (Duh!) Apparently such a course of action had never occured to him before, but then perhaps he was afraid that his job as an "official wall-scraper" would henceforth be in jeopardy.
Good article! I agree that the Kristian Perspective was the best part of The Mirror and that it had become exceedingly stale by the time it was shuttered. What I liked best, however, is reading about what makes you tick as a writer! Great stuff!
ReplyDelete