Friday, September 20, 2019

Quebec's scandal of the century: how arson, fraud and murder caused panic in 1965

Payette
Francois Payette, 36, awoke at his impressive riverside mansion at 9029 Gouin W. one Saturday morning 9:30 in February 1966, strapped on his horn-rimmed glasses and embarked on his rounds collecting on money that he had lent out.  
   The Montreal lawyer went about his business and by 2:30 was ready to meet another borrower to take payment.
    The next time Payette was seen he was lifeless in his trunk with two bullets through his head and three others in the rest of his body.
   The five killer bullets flew from two different guns held by murderers who were never caught.
Payette's automobile of doom
   His was believed to be the eighth body that fell as a result of a calamitous fraud, bankruptcy and murder ring that wreaked havoc in Quebec and led Justice Minister Claude Wagner to the brink of panic, calling it the "scandal of the century" and leading the provincial police to torture suspects.
  Payette, who specialized in bankruptcy cases, was likely killed because he was ready to come clean to prosecutors concerning a $150,000 scam that saw a Quebec City lumber firm defrauded by a company that purchased merchandise and declared bankruptcy rather than paying the bill.
     Many gangs were involved in a variety of such scams but all roads pointed to crafty Quebec City businessman Moise Darabaner.
**
Moise Darabaner
   In 1965 Moise Darabaner was a low-key mortgage broker manager and a commissioner of the Superior Court of Quebec for a dozen years. His best fishing pal was a top cop in the city and Darabaner oversaw one of the most important political events of his era, likely while ordering murders on the side. .
  Two year earlier Darabaner invited six Social Credit MPs to his Quebec City office where they renounced their party to join Lester Pearson's Liberals. The spectacular political coup cemented Pearson's wobbly government and doomed the So-Creds.
   Darabaner personally swore the members to a formal affidavit, which he sent it to the Governor General, making their switch official.
   In so doing he incurred the white-hot wrath of So-Cred whip Dr. Guy Marcoux, who led a campaign claiming the defections were the result of bribery and trickery. Marcoux penned a 24-page scathing attack on all involved in the "l'affaire des six."
   Darabaner had previously only made news once, in 1955, when he was ordered to remove the third floor from a half-dozen houses he had built in Quebec City in an area that only permitted two-storey buildings.
**
Quebec saw an average of one arson per day in the mid-1960s, many of which were set for insurance fraud. A half dozen people died in such arson attacks and that also forced consumers to pay much higher rates for their insurance.
Police searched woods for bodies in 1965
   In one case a hotel was torched in the town of Lac Frontiere, but the flames spread to a lumber operation and crippled the town's economy.
  The same criminal gangs would also organize profitable  bankruptcies, of which there were 8,500 in Quebec in 1964, leaving debts of $390 million.
   Many scams were simple: buy items on credit, resell them and declare bankruptcy without paying your debt.
   The soldiers of such scams included Ovila Boulet, an illiterate thug from Quebec City who pleaded guilty to torching 52 places. Jean Jacques Gagnon, an inveterate gambler, was convicted of two counts of murder. Andre Lamothe was also busted for murder while Andre Becotte was nailed for finding companies vulnerable to the lure of arson schemes.
 
    Julien Gagnon, a friend of legendary criminal Lucien Rivard, supplied arsonists with a special gas that would hide the telltale odour of smell of the incendiary liquid used to set blazes.
   Darabaner would recruit such criminals through his criminal lawyer friends who rubbed shoulders with thugs on a regular basis.
   Darabaner would sometimes lend money for housing mortgages that he knew the owner would be unable to pay back. In one case he lent $4,000 to Cora B. Cyr for a house in Levis. When she was unable to make her payments Darabaner had the home torched and split the insurance money with her.
   Another frequent scam was to remove items from a property before torching it, so the arsonists could claim the lost goods while also keeping the lost goods. In one case a massive warehouse fire saw $1 million in canned food lost for flames only to reappear in a Quebec City warehouse.
   Arson gangs would also provide fake phone numbers for phony bank managers who'd provide solid credit references, a system that became increasingly elaborate and complicated.
Clockwise top left: Andre Lamothe,
Ovila Boulet, Fernand Quiron
Jean-Jacques Gagnon
    In some cases a company would buy lumber without paying and then declare bankruptcy. Then a sister company inherited the lumber and then built cottages with it which they'd then burn down for a double payoff.
  **
   Provincial Justice Minister Claude Wagner was highly irritated by the scams and appointed Gerard Laganiere special prosecutor. He, in turn, set up a system where various levels of police would share information and give him tips.
   The squad got lucky in June 1964 when anti-terrorist police searching for FLQ cells instead stumbled across files on fake bankruptcies worth $20 million.
   Armand Becotte became an informant and his gang was busted.
   Two months later the squad got another break when Rachel Smiley, 62, complained that Darabaner had been swindled her company Junior Holdings out of a $115,000 deposit for his promise to help her land government contracts.
    Cops put the squeeze on Darabaner's associate Gaston Constantin who was given police protection as a witness against Darabaner, who was charged with fraud in August 1965.
   Constantin told prosecutors that Darabaner had offered him $1,000 to kill Rachel Smiley, which he turned down. Darabaner then negotiated with another to do the job.
   Constantin also also fingered Darabaner as the culprit behind behind a March 1965 fire at a former longtime Quebec City wrestling palladium known as La Tour, which has since been turned into a government warehouse.

Darabaner, aged 43, in August 1965
 In September Darabaner faced new charges stemming from these revelations and he eventually pleaded guilty and was sentenced to nine years in the pen.
   He was finally relieved of his post as Commissioner of the Superior Court on October 19.
   On Halloween 1965 Jean Paul Villeneuve, 21, died in a building Darabaner owned at the corner of St. Jeanand St. Stanislas in old Quebec City. Darabaner had run a restaurant on the ground floor of the historic fieldstone building as St. Leon, but it was now called Chez Den. Police believe Villeneuve accidentally set the blaze with a cigarette but the story kept Darabaner in the headlines.
   Darabaner was out after seven years and apparently returned to obscurity, although one report has him rearrested in 1973 and another suggested he was a gambling addict.

**
   The body count throughout this mess was high,however, as potential witnesses against Darabaner dropped like rain, as seven bodies turned up, while Wagner said the real number was up to a dozen.
   The bodies of Alderic Bilodeau, whose hotel was torched, arsonist Redempteur Faucher and Paul Brie were found together in late September 1965 in Lotbiniere.
   One of Darabaner's close associates, Henri-Paul Chardonnet, was found dead in Ham South, 40miles from Sherbrooke a few weeks later.
   Others killed were Marcel Gingras, found in the woods in St. Ferdinand d'Halifax, Paul Nadeau in St. Nicolas and another whose name was not revealed in the Bois Francs region of the Eastern Townships.
   **
 In October 1965 provincial police questioned Louis Sicotte, an insurance adjuster from St. Lambert. They suspected him of being involved with the Darabaner crew and in their interrogation they managed to inflict what he later described as 16 broken ribs, a fractured pelvis, band many other injuries.
   He claimed in a lawsuit that 18 QPP officers were present for the torture inflicted at their McGill Street headquarters while he was denied the right to see his  lawyer.
Sicotte
   Sicotte denied any wrongdoing and police eventually brought him to a motel where they threatened to charge him with arson if he didn't sign a paper saying that he suffered the injuries in an innocent fall. He agreed to sign the papers but later recanted.
   A doctor eventually came to see Sicotte and he was hospitalized for two weeks.
   Sicotte was given a suspended sentence in August 1966 but was unable to work due to his injuries.
   He sued for $250,000. The government claimed that the suit was laid too late and could not be heard.
  An inquiry was held into police conduct in connection with the investigation but Wagner declared that the investigation turned up no wrongdoing.

2 comments:

  1. Amazing how many awful crimes have gone unpunished in Quebec.

    I wonder how the investigation is proceeding regarding the remains of the infant discovered hidden in the ceiling of 597 Victoria, Westmount, following renovation work back in January of 2017? Presumably the authorities have reached some conclusions by now?

    Was the child aborted, stillborn, a victim of infanticide, or of accidental death? Was it born to a family member resident of that address or perhaps to a servant, patient, or friend?

    Given the small size of the corpse, you would think that it would have been so much easier to dispose of it far away in some remote area rather than keep it on the premises--which suggests a scenario based on panic. Imagine living in a house knowing there is a hidden corpse over your head! Just like in the movies.

    Is there anyone with direct knowledge still alive today who can be tracked down and questioned? Was anyone--perhaps a teenager--seen to be pregnant back then but who never appeared in public with her child or perhaps she and the entire family suddenly and mysteriously moved out of the home without a reasonable excuse? Is there a neighbour who had suspicions back then now willing to speak up?

    According to the sparse news reports, the approximate time-frame of the concealment suggests 1936-1961 based on the corpse being wrapped in newspapers having articles about Quebec Premier Maurice Duplessis. DNA analysis would presumably narrow it down and a match obtained.

    Therefore, Kristian, given your comprehensive access to local criminal cases, research material, and personal contacts, perhaps you could do a little digging of your own?

    Since Lovell's Directory lists those resident at the address during the aforementioned time-frame, I will not post their names here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I’m related to the Darabaners through marriage. My great-uncle was Moise’s father-in-law.

    ReplyDelete

Love to get comments! Please, please, please speak your mind !
Links welcome - please google "how to embed a link" it'll make your comment much more fun and clickable.